Canon

Why Star War’s Canon Failures Are Actually The Best For The Franchise

Few sagas have as many inconsistencies and canonical retcons as star wars, but these are actually a good thing for the franchise. Starting in 1977 as a big bet, star wars quickly became a global phenomenon that is now a major part of pop culture. Despite the periods without film releases, star wars has never left the popular imagination and has remained a treasured brand.

This is largely due to the fact that star wars expanded into other media. In addition to the movies themselves, books, comics, games, and TV shows have become the epitome of not only the Skywalker saga, but also other stories within star wars. Disney’s acquisition of Lucasfilm changed the rules on canon and continuity, but the making of more and more star wars content for different media has never stopped.

Related: Star Wars: What If Rian Johnson Directed The Rise of Skywalker?

A legacy of over forty years crafted by different creators in different media also means there are many canonical inconsistencies. No matter in what order we watch the Star Wars Movies, puzzles and intrigue will be part of the experience. Although theoretically negative, these barrel failures and timing gaps are unavoidable and can help star wars always feeling alive and open to new interpretations thus being the best for the franchise.

Star Wars collects plot holes and inconsistencies

Star wars theory Obi wan kenobi age conspiracy hole alec guinness

From Luke and Leia revealed as siblings in Return of the Jedi after kissing The Empire Strikes Back to Kanan’s Order 66 experience being different in comics and animation, star wars not only collects plot holes, but also dozens of retcons based on said plot holes. The original trilogy alone had a long list of inconsistencies, including but not limited to why Vader could sense Luke was his son but not Leia, why Luke seems to have spent a few weeks training with Yoda when Leia and Han Solo were with Lando in Cloud City for what felt like just a few days, or why the Emperor never pursued Skywalker’s children if he knew of them.

In relation to the plots that would emerge with the making of the star wars prequel trilogy, however, the mentioned inconsistencies seem minimal. By setting the star wars 30 years before the Battle of Yavin, George Lucas had the chance to show the origins of iconic characters like Darth Vader/Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi, but the creative choices made by the lone director and screenwriter ended up adding big holes in an already convoluted saga. Obi-Wan was no longer Yoda’s only student as suggested by The Empire Strikes Back but instead, the apprentice of a never-before-mentioned Jedi name, Qui-Gon Jin; local Tatooine clothing happened to be the same clothing all Jedi used; Leia’s mother, Padmé, died in childbirth although Leia said she remembered her; Obi-Wan knew R2-D2 and had an R4 despite stating in the original film that he had never owned a droid, and the “Darth” in Darth Vader was no longer a given name as suggested in the movie. ‘original. star wars but now a title shared by other villains.

Why Star Wars Canon Has So Many Errors

Star Wars Clone Wars Anakin Prequels

A franchise that has been around for 45 years in different media is bound to have canon inconsistencies, no matter how well planned. In the case of star wars, in which new backstory and important events are always written and gaps are always filled in, it is even more understandable. As important as canon is to much of the fanbase, for a long time the creative wishes of George Lucas and anyone who bought a license to write star wars eclipsed any attempt to establish a single, cohesive story.

Related: Why Does Yoda Call Luke The Last Jedi (When Ahsoka & Ezra Exist)?

star wars‘ his own design was to produce canonical inconsistencies as the stories of the first three films were undefined from the outset. Until the second draft of The Empire Strikes BackDarth Vader wasn’t even supposed to be Luke’s father – which goes to show just how little ahead of the major points of star wars were planned. That said, many star wars‘ plot holes could have been avoided – especially those from the prequel trilogy. George Lucas had three story, date, and background films to write the prequel trilogy about, but the director preferred to go against what he had already established. It should be noted that the prequel trilogy was made more than ten years after Return of the Jedi, meaning Lucas must have changed his mind about the story he was telling. The director wasn’t afraid to reenact his creation, and so elements like Yoda not being Obi-Wan’s sole master or Luke and Leia’s mother dying in childbirth came to light. Essentially, in Lucas’s eyes, these inconsistencies were a price to pay.

In addition to the prequel trilogy, another factor that contributes to plot holes in star wars this is how it became a transmedia franchise. Even before Disney acquired Lucasfilm, the star wars saga was already told through books, comics, animated series and video games. When so much content is being created, and usually by completely different creative teams and studios, maintaining consistency is extremely difficult.

How Disney Tried To Fix Star Wars Canon

Endless Star Wars Legends Gave Star Wars Its Own What If Luke Skywalker

Maintaining consistency was exactly the mission Disney set for itself after buying Lucasfilm. In fact, before Disney, there had never been an official star wars cannon. Everything George Lucas had a say in, including all six movies and Star Wars: The Clone Warswere obviously as “canon” as anything could get, but there was nothing to say that a book from the star wars The Expanded Universe or a video game was not part of the official story. However, the fact that the definition of star wars the canon was so loose created so many inconsistencies that Disney had to try some sort of reorganization, especially to have a clean slate for the sequel trilogy. This is when all books, comics and video games released before the acquisition were declared non-canon and labeled Legends.

The decision was controversial, but it ensured that for the first time in decades star wars had a well-defined canon and timeline. This particularly helped new audiences, who now knew what they should and shouldn’t consume to follow the Skywalker saga. However, not even Disney’s Lucasfilm was able to prevent every plot hole or canon inconsistency from occurring. Star Wars: The Bad Batchwhich showed a different Order 66 moment for Kanan and his master than the story shown in Disney’s post-purchase comic arc, is just one example.

Related: Star Wars Theory Reveals Obi-Wan Knew R2-D2 In A New Hope (& Why He Lied)

Star Wars will never have a perfect canon – and that’s awesome

Almost half a century after the first star wars The movie is out, the saga still doesn’t have perfect canon, and there’s no sign that things will start to change. This, however, is not necessarily a bad thing. As the examples cited in this article demonstrate, star wars was born out of retcons and last-minute changes, and much of the saga’s charm comes from those little anecdotes and age-old debates such as working out the right order to watch the star wars movies.

In the real world, history is rarely a matter of clear and established fact, written by victors, and includes skewed or poorly remembered accounts of events. Real-world history is also filled with myths and legends that might once have been based on factual ideas but have since been dismissed as fiction. the original star wars 1977 nodded to this idea with Han Solo dismissing the idea that Jedi and the Force were real. The endless retcons and conflicting stories that appear in the star wars canon of the universe and in Legends helping to be part of what makes all the stories told around George Lucas’ brainchild feel more real and part of a larger reality. The story in the real world is flawed, and star wars‘ the absence of a perfect canon makes it richer by reflecting this aspect.

More than that, the constant mission not only of the public but also of the creators to fill in the gaps and correct the star wars Plot holes and retcons can often be the start of fresh new stories that end up adding a lot to the saga. Obi Wan Kenobiwhich will further develop the relationship between Vader and Obi-Wan despite A A new hope doubting what their last encounter was, is a prime example. Essentially having to improve the story and explain the gaps in the timeline, something looks like clone wars and The Mandalorian have been so successful, is one of the reasons why star wars remains a living saga that is still a commercial success.

Next: Star Wars: What if Ahsoka had joined Maul at the end of Clone Wars?

  • Rogue Squadron (2023)Release date: December 22, 2023

The Thor Love and Thunder trailer bucked two annoying trends

Thor: Love & Thunder’s trailer bucked 2 annoying modern trends


About the Author